Cumberland Times-News

Opinion

January 14, 2013

‘Ill-conceived’

Container deposit bill bad for state’s businesses

 Maryland businesses will take another hit this year if legislation is approved in the General Assembly to have customers pay a 5 cent refundable deposit on cans and bottles bought in the state.

While the bill, planned by Del. Maggie McIntosh a Democrat from Baltimore City, is touted as an environment measure aimed at increasing recycling, it will also have considerable economic ramifications for customers and businesses alike. The Maryland Retailers Association said in a statement the proposal would be a new tax on consumers and it called the measure an “ill-conceived, outdated and ineffective approach to encourage recycling.”

According to the Baltimore Business Journal the bill is expected to triple the percentage of cans and bottles that are recycled in Maryland to as much as 75 percent. Currently, about 22 percent of 4 billon cans and bottles bought in the state each year are recycled.

Although it is difficult to oppose efforts to improve the state’s recycling programs, piling on a 5-cent deposit on cans and bottles is certain to drive up soft drink and beer prices. Anytime prices go up on beverages or cigarettes, Maryland drives more customers across state lines to buy their products where the costs are not as great.

Deposit bills have been defeated previously in the General Assembly. This year, McIntosh plans to make the program voluntary in the hopes of having her measure win approval.  Retailers won’t have to participate in the recycling program, although McIntosh said she expects that many will.

That is another problem with the legislation. Some stores will add the deposit, some will not. Consumers, meanwhile, will be thoroughly confused.

There are other ways to encourage bottle and can recycling in the state. Senators and delegates should focus on those alternatives and once again scrap the deposit bill.

Text Only
Opinion
  • High priority High priority

    Maryland school officials on Tuesday put an exclamation point on the need to take student-athlete concussions more seriously.

    May 22, 2013 1 Photo

  • Why are there no answers to these questions?

    We currently have the most corrupt administration in the history of the country. Every day more and more lies come from the Obama administration.

    May 22, 2013

  • Roaming dogs prove menace to some residents of LaVale

    I am writing to inform your readers and the animal control staff of Allegany about a problem that is dragging on and unresolved, yet.

    May 22, 2013

  • These types should look to the Boy Scouts for an example

    Consider these headlines:
    NRA will “Never Surrender.”
    The Tea Party will “Never Surrender.”
    The No Tax Group will “Never surrender.”
    Neocons will “Never Surrender.”
    Far Left Liberals will “Never Surrender.”

    May 22, 2013

  • Housing project will have bad effect on property in this area

    I am writing to you to voice my opposition to a low income housing project that has been proposed for construction on a tract of land on Pine Swamp Road in Mineral County, W.Va. I am a registered voter and resident of Mineral County and live in the New Creek/Pine Swamp area.

    May 22, 2013

  • Why have the media been silent all this time?

    When I read the Cumberland Times-News Editorial this morning, Friday, May 17, entitled, “Outrageous,” I laughed like a kid at a birthday party!

    May 21, 2013

  • What are chances this much money will be spent on road?

    I was intrigued by cost data summarized in reporter Kathy Mellott’s recent article, “Completing southern link of U.S. Route 219 said to be best use of highway funds,” which appeared in the Cumberland Times-News on Tuesday May 14 (Page 1A).

    May 21, 2013

  • School board should be doing better job with less money

    The Allegany County Teachers Association (ACTA) board of directors recently submitted a letter to the editor asking the Allegany County commissioners to fully fund the Board of Education’s budget request for the upcoming fiscal year (“Commissioners should fund school board request,” April 29 Times-News).

    May 21, 2013

  • Better ‘Click It’ Better ‘Click It’

    If you notice more police on the highway this week, it’s for a couple of reasons.

    May 20, 2013 1 Photo

  • Were they really good old days? You decide

    When a fellow gets old, it’s not unusual for his mind to wander back to the days of his youth. He may forget where he laid his glasses five minutes ago, yet he can remember events that took place a half a century ago. This is one of the interesting things of old age.

    May 20, 2013