Cumberland Times-News

Local News

May 28, 2011

Missouri model may be used for changes in juvenile justice system

In Maryland, 56 percent of delinquents rearrested within three years of release from treatment centers

BALTIMORE — Ask some Maryland leaders interested in juvenile justice what they think of the state’s system, and they say it’s not working. Ask them how they’d reform it, and many point to the model used in Missouri.

In Missouri, less than 10 percent of delinquents return to the Division of Youth Services within three years after release from a treatment facility. In Maryland, 56 percent are rearrested within three years. Missouri receives national praise for rehabilitating delinquent youth in a system that uses small, regional treatment centers, improved training for staff and carefully crafted treatment programs.

Yet Maryland has made few changes that would push it toward the Missouri model, despite efforts by some lawmakers and advocates. And Sam J. Abed, who became Maryland’s secretary of juvenile services in February, says he’s not sure the Missouri system is a perfect fit here.

“Maryland has a lot of issues that need to be resolved that Missouri is not facing,” Abed said.

But those who believe in the Missouri system say Maryland should adapt it to generate reforms here. “I don’t think there are any operational or statutory barriers to doing the Missouri model,” said Bart Lubow, director of juvenile justice strategic group for the Annie E. Casey Foundation.

“You don’t need to reinvent the wheel when we have a state that’s been as successful as Missouri,” said Maryland state Sen. Bobby Zirkin, who has introduced many bills to move the state in that direction.

About 160,000 youths enter the Maryland juvenile system each year — with more of them coming from Baltimore than from any other jurisdiction. They are, generally, as young as 11 and some are more than 18 years old. They range from runaways to murderers. More than half will return to the system within three years of release.

“There’s no area that’s more dysfunctional in the state,” Zirkin said. “We are a failure statistically.” Last year, Zirkin sponsored a bill to limit the size of facilities to 48 beds. That number is significantly less than that of most Maryland centers for delinquent youth. But in Missouri, the average size of youth facilities is 30 beds.

Advocates believe that smaller centers mean that teenagers get more attention and the chance for better treatment. But they say the state needs to do much more to help teen-agers — to improve their lives and to protect public safety.

The system, advocates say, needs better training for its staff; treatment programs that involve families and community members, and centers that are less like prisons.     But people who want to change the system keep meeting opposition — political and financial.

Mark Steward, former director of the Division of Youth Services in Missouri, says it took his state 20 years to revamp the system. Marylanders who want to change programs here must begin somewhere. “It’s been a long journey but if you don’t start someplace, you’ll never get there,” he said.

Abed, Maryland’s new juvenile services secretary, says he has begun to identify problems he believes must be fixed soon. Among them: “pending placement.”

In Maryland, juveniles sit in detention centers after they have already faced a judge, awaiting placement in a regional or out-of-state treatment center for weeks, if not months, because those centers are full. “Missouri has enough space for its kids,” Abed said.

Maryland’s department goal is to move juveniles from detention to their placement — either probation or in a treatment facility — within 25 days. The average length of stay for juveniles in detention centers last year was 30 days. And advocates say that number hides the reality that many wait much longer. “We know there are kids sitting there for four months,” Lubow said.

But many leaders say the pending placement problem can be resolved if the department embraces the Missouri approach. Missouri supporters believe using the model would reduce the number of kids who reenter the system. That would help ease the pending placement problem and would improve public safety.

“In Maryland, it’s very doable,” said Steward. “The Maryland system is amenable to making the kinds of programs that work for kids.”     

Abed plans to gather all the partners that work collectively within the juvenile justice system: judges, attorneys, advocates and other state agencies. He says he needs to ensure partners all agree on an approach.

Text Only
Local News
  • UNDEFEATED STATE CHAMPS! UNDEFEATED STATE CHAMPS!

    Mountain Ridge softball head coach Martha Mauzy and players react after the Miners’ 4-3 win over Mardela in the Maryland 1A state championship game at the University of Maryland on Saturday.

    May 26, 2012 1 Photo

  • Officials hoping flight school takes off

    Opening a flight school at the Greater Cumberland Regional Airport and further developing the health care corridor along Willowbrook Road are two ways officials think the local economy can grow.

    May 26, 2012

  • Former mayors seek Keyser council seat

    Challenger Terry Liller, incumbent Ed Miller Sr., former Mayor Roger Newlin and former Mayor William “Sonny” Rhodes, all candidates for Keyser City Council, all have an opinion on the recall election and citizen complaints and concerns made during recent council meetings.

    May 26, 2012

  • Parents’ dilemma: Let children play football?

    Already uneasy about the idea of letting her 7-year-old son Jason start playing tackle football, Elizabeth Giancarli made up her mind when former NFL star Junior Seau committed suicide.

    May 26, 2012

  • Slow going Slow going

    May 26, 2012 1 Photo

  • Neighbors battle brush on Woodside Ave. Neighbors battle brush on Woodside Ave.

    You could sweat sitting still on Woodside Avenue Saturday afternoon, to say nothing of the perspiration that pulling weeds, gathering trash and painting a guardrail would bring on.

    May 26, 2012 1 Photo

  • DelFest, county fairgrounds continue to evolve DelFest, county fairgrounds continue to evolve

    Allegany County Fairgrounds manager Kevin Kamauf talked Saturday of the logistical aspects of putting together DelFest and the ever-expanding fairgrounds that plays host to the annual Memorial Day event.

    May 26, 2012 1 Photo

  • Just waiting for their day to come Just waiting for their day to come

    The annual Memorial Day Super Cruise spanned along six businesss on Industrial Boulevard Saturday.

    May 26, 2012 1 Photo

  • Summer school options varied

    The Allegany County Public School System is offering a variety of summer school options that require registration by Friday.

    May 26, 2012

  • Farmers markets due at two new sites

    The Allegany Mountain Fresh Producers Association will have farmers markets at two new locations this year and add four new vendors, according to co-chairman Jack Miltenberger.

    May 26, 2012