WASHINGTON — Contrary to what critics say, students are not at risk of being shoved out of spots in Maryland community colleges or universities if the DREAM Act is upheld, said a new University of Maryland, Baltimore County study released this week.
The report “Private and Government Fiscal Costs and Benefits of the Maryland Dream Act” was coauthored by professors Thomas Gindling and Marvin Mandell at the Maryland Institute for Policy Analysis and Research. It measures the economic im-pact of the DREAM Act — for Development Relief and Education for Alien Minors — on government, schools and students.
The study found that “crowding-out effects,” an argument used against the DREAM Act by opponents such as the Help Save Maryland campaign, are unlikely in Maryland due to the requirement that students must spend at least two years at a community college before attending a four-year degree program. This may reduce the number of undocumented immigrants in freshmen classes at four-year universities. The report also predicted that the number of undocumented students transferring from community colleges to other universities will be low — only 102 students a year.
The report fills a void in the debate over the DREAM Act, Gindling said.
“What we saw as missing was numbers in cost and benefit analysis,” he said.
Gindling and Mandell’s yearlong research found that one cost of the DREAM Act would fall on state universities. The 12 state schools would experience a total $1.8 million drop, or about .1 percent, from lost out-of-state tuition. Government subsidies will not cover the loss.
However the cost is small compared to what the study predicted would be the total net economic benefit: $66 million for each annual cohort of students. And that may be an underestimate, the report said, because of the difficulty in measuring the impacts of increased educational attainment.
Gindling said he hopes the report will add depth to the discussions surrounding the state law.
“What we hope is it will make the discussion possibly less emotional and more about the actual outcomes,” he said.
The research, however, does not have everyone convinced the DREAM Act will be beneficial to Maryland.
“Here’s another shortcoming in the Maryland higher education system,” said Brad Botwin, director of Help Save Maryland, about the report. “They used some real shoddy analysis.”
Some of the numbers cited he called “laughable.” The number of students the study estimated as taking advantage of the DREAM Act, 435, he said is too low. It’s more like 1,000, Botwin said. The research also is skewed, he said, because UMBC’s president, Freeman A. Hrabowski, III, is a supporter of the act.
Botwin said he worries that the DREAM Act will create a slippery slope that will lead to laws like California’s, where undocumented students qualify for, not only in-state tuition, but state-funded financial aid.
The DREAM Act will be overwhelmingly positive for Maryland, Gindling said, and “repealing the Dream Act could be very costly.”
Latest news
DREAM Act won’t crowd out citizen students
Study cites community college requirement
- Latest news
-
-
County: Increase in water rates planned
Many customers in Allegany County will likely see a small increase in their water and sewer rates during the upcoming fiscal year.
-
Rocky Gap Casino Resort flush with visitors; 1,000 estimated on first day
Nearly 300 people were waiting outside and in the lobby Wednesday when Rocky Gap Casino Resort officials emerged at about 4 p.m. to announce they had received a call from the Maryland gaming commission that they were approved to open.
-
Live music takes center stage at 6th DelFest
With more than 30 musical acts set to take the stage at the 6th annual DelFest this weekend, now might be a good time to let folks know about some of the bands that will headline this four-day music festival.
-
Bear in tree
A crew from the Maryland Wildlife & Heritage Service successfully removed a young female bear from a tree in South Cumberland Thursday morning, eventually releasing the bruin on state-owned land in Allegany County.
-
Frostburg adopts $9.7M budget, keeps alley open
The Frostburg mayor and city council have voted to adopt a $9.7 million budget for fiscal year 2014 and to keep open an alley that many citizens feared would be closed by the city.
-
6th annual DelFest has arrived
Thirty national recording artists are preparing to step into the Cumberland spotlight this weekend at the Allegany County Fairgrounds as DelFest rolls into town for its sixth annual musical festival.
- Rocky Gap casino opens
-
‘Time just kind of stood still’
Helmeted rescue workers raced Tuesday to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of nine children.
-
City hopes economic strategies clear way for job creation, growth
Shawn Hershberger, economic development coordinator for the city, gave an update of the strategies being pursued for economic growth, including developing an educational center at the former Human Resources Development Commission location.
-
Protesters rally at FirstEnergy meeting
At least 200 union workers picketed FirstEnergy’s annual shareholder meeting in West Virginia on Tuesday, demanding the Ohio-based utility hire enough people to keep the power on without forcing an ever-shrinking labor force to work as many as 1,800 hours of overtime a year.
- More Latest news Headlines
-
County: Increase in water rates planned
