Cumberland Times-News

Bob Doyle - Astronomy

February 5, 2009

Must birds, bats be hurt by wind farms?

As an example, consider the Dan’s Mountain Wind Farm Project where likely 25 large wind turbines will be erected to convert wind energy into electrical energy for the electrical grid.

Each of the turbines will have three blades, each about 48 meters long and two meters wide. The area of the blades as they rotate will be (Pi*radius2 ) 7240 square meters or 1.8 acres. So the entire wind area used by these wind turbines will be about 45 acres.

Dan’s Mountain Wind Force, LLC has leased about 2,000 acres, covering a length of four miles or 6,440 m of which the towers will sit on 150 acres that will be cleared.

The towers are positioned at least 10 rotor diameters apart or 960 meters apart, the width of 10 football fields. (If they are closer, they will interfere with each other’s wind flow and lower their efficiency.) So if the towers are spaced every 960 meters, the free space (not in the rotor swing) is about 90 percent for a line of wind turbines.

Now due to Bernoulli’s Principle, as the wind increases the pressure drops. Will these wind turbines be change the wind velocity, resulting in lower pressure and then sucking birds and bats into their sweeping area?

You have experienced Bernoulli’s Principle when on a gusty, rainy day, your umbrella will suddenly turn itself inside out. (Faster air on top of the umbrella will have lower pressure than the air just below the umbrella; this creates a pressure difference to push up on umbrella and cause the wire supports to flip up instead of down.)

By noticing the wind blades in the nearby Pocahontas, Pa., wind farm, their 30-meter long blades typically spin all the way around in two seconds on a windy day. (There are twenty 1.35 megawatts towers in this wind farm that have operating for several years. You can see them easily by taking the Finzel Exit on I-68 and traveling north into Pennsylvania.)

Their tip blade velocity will be 94 m/s or 339 km/sec or 211 mi/hr. So the speed of the blade (which depends on distance from the axis) can be as fast as a dozen times a strong wind. (If the wind is too strong, the wind turbines are shut down.)

So at the tip of the wind turbine blades, the speed is comparable to the air speed of a propeller driven plane; this would lower the air pressure around the turning rotor blades. (In the recent New York airplane incident where the pilot landed his plane in the Hudson River, some large birds were sucked into both engines at over 3000 feet altitude, causing the engines to shut down.)

This Bernoulli drop in the air pressure will weaken with distance from the turning rotors. (So these turbines will not be acting like huge vacuum cleaners, drawing objects and debris into them and likely scarring the fiber glass blades, and shortening their service life.)

I have suggested in several past columns that ultrasonic speakers be placed on the towers beneath the spinning rotors. These ultrasonic speakers, powered by each turbine’s own electricity, would send out alarm signals to both bats and birds, driving them away from the towers when the rotor blades were turning.

Ultrasonic means a frequency beyond the human hearing range, but disturbing to winged creatures near the towers. Some readers may have small external devices on their cars that catch the air and shriek at frequencies that drive away deer.

Perhaps you have used a dog whistle. Why can’t even more powerful noise speakers be used for the towers to protect birds and bats? It has been suggested that such devices be installed on passenger planes to avoid collisions with flocks of birds.

Tomorrow evening we have a full moon, appearing near the bright star Regulus of Leo. (Regulus was one of the four Royal Stars of Persia, four bright stars that appear along the moon’s path; the other three stars are Aldebaran in Taurus, Spica in Virgo and Antares in the Scorpion).

On the next two evenings, the moon will appear near the planet Saturn; the moon will be above and to the right of Saturn on Tuesday evening and below and to the left of Saturn on Wednesday evening.

This Friday is Feb. 13, which will repeat in March and November of this year. Actually, there are slightly more Friday the 13ths, than Saturday, Sunday, and Thursday the 13ths. Most years have at least one or two Friday the 13ths , with about 15 percent of years having three.

In the southeastern dawn (about 6:20 a.m.), the planet Mercury can be seen close to the horizon. About half hour later, the bright planet Jupiter rises. In February’s last week, Jupiter and Mercury appear close.

Now showing at the Frostburg State Planetarium is “Tropical Skies”, exploring unusual sky sights seen near the equator. We also include an informal tour of our current evening skies. Our programs are at 4 p.m. and 7 p.m. on Sundays. All of our presentations are free and live, allowing questions during the program. I regularly stop talking and let questions be asked.

The Planetarium is in Tawes 302. Tawes is a medium sized building with its name on the front, across the street from the larger 4 storey Compton Science Center. Tawes is in back (northwest) of the Performing Arts Center. There is convenient free nearby parking, for on Sundays there are no regular classes at Frostburg State.

For any comments or questions from readers, contact Bob Doyle either by phone (301)687-7799 or email ( rdoyle@frostburg.edu ).

Text Only
Bob Doyle - Astronomy
  • Here’s your chance to meet the bears

    This afternoon our weekly Sunday programs will resume at 4 p.m. in the Compton Science Center, Room 224. Compton is the large building across the Tawes Hall, set for demolition. 

    February 4, 2012

  • Scientists are uncovering Earth’s distant past

     Powerful telescopes can look far away (also far back in time) to learn about the early universe; earth scientists using radioactive dating and isotopic analysis can investigate the first few billion years of our Earth’s history.

    January 28, 2012

  • Teachers must show what is important

    As well as teaching college, I do sessions in the elementary schools and frequent public presentations; I feel I have a good sense of what makes an impression on my listeners.

    January 21, 2012

  • Students can become self-directed learners

    The last of seven principles featured in the book “How Learning Works” is influencing students to become self-directed learners. This applies primarily to what students do out of class, involving homework, studying for tests, doing papers and assignments. 

    January 14, 2012

  • Here’s how students organize knowledge

    The 2010 book, “How Learning Works” by five researchers in the Pittsburgh area has a wealth of insights as to how teachers can influence students to be more effective learners.

    January 7, 2012

  • Here are the best sky sights through June

    Thanks to the predictive power of astronomy, here are the best bare eye or binocular sights in the first half of 2012. 

    January 1, 2012

  • Tawes Hall was site of many good memories

    In a few weeks, the interior of Frostburg State’s Tawes Hall will start to be gutted; in a month or so, the outside walls will begin to be knocked down.

    December 24, 2011

  • Students need motivation to learn

     Most teachers from elementary to college often wonder, “How can I get some of my students motivated? Then they could learn a great deal more in class, from their readings and from their assignments.” 

    December 17, 2011

  • Prior knowledge can affect your learning

    This column will review the first of the seven principles from “How Learning Works,” one of the most significant books in education in recent years. This principle is “How Does Students’ Prior Knowledge Affect Their Learning?”

    December 10, 2011

  • Seasons and solstices mark the year’s passage

    Many think that in winter, we are farthest from the sun. There is also a widespread belief that in summer we are closest to the sun. In truth, both beliefs are wrong. The Earth-Sun distance varies by 3.4 per cent through the year while the solar insolation (watts/square meter) at midday on a flat surface varies by 80 per cent. 

    December 3, 2011